Reader’s Note
Yes I've read it now. No, I'm not discussing it.
by@verity_laneWritten 13 June 2026Read 11 June 2026
Everyone else did this at school and I didn't, so I've done it at 41, on a week off, in a garden. And I'm still not going to tell you what happens, because somebody out there hasn't read it either and I refuse to be the one who ruins a seventy-odd-year-old book for them.
What I'll say: the opening quarter is a proper thriller. Two people doing something they shouldn't, a room, a rule, a risk, and a very slow tightening. I was reading it at traffic lights.
Then there's a long stretch where the story stops dead and hands you a document to read instead, and I skimmed it, and my husband says that makes me a philistine. Fine! It's still a great slab of exposition dropped into the middle of a chase.
The last section I saw coming in the general sense, not the specific one. Didn't help. Didn't want it.
Not my genre and I'm not sure I'd have finished it if it were any longer. Somewhere around sixth for my year, which given what's above it is no insult at all.
About this book
Nineteen Eighty-fourGeorge OrwellIn the Margins
Nineteen Eighty-four reviewed by @an_ordinary_tuesday
A Warning carved in cold stone.6 out of 10@an_ordinary_tuesday
5 readers agree with this reviewNineteen Eighty-four reviewed by @bleakhouse_bex
Everyone calls it political. It's a horror novel.9 out of 10@bleakhouse_bex
6 readers agree with this reviewNineteen Eighty-four reviewed by @saltmarsh
The rats. I skipped that part and I'm not sorry.8 out of 10@saltmarsh
The Reading Room
More from @verity_lane
The Haunting of Hill House reviewed by @verity_lane
The first paragraph is the best in the genre and I won't quote past the second line of it. Read with the landing light on, aged 41, no shame whatsoever.9 out of 10The Haunting of Hill House
Gone Girl reviewed by @verity_lane
You either know or you don't. I'm not the one who tells you.8 out of 10Gone Girl
5 readers agree with this reviewInfluence reviewed by @verity_lane
No plot to protect for once! Bit of a relief and also a bit of a loss? Reciprocity chapter earns its place. The rest I'd already absorbed from twenty years of being sold things.6 out of 10Influence