Reader’s Note
You either know or you don't. I'm not the one who tells you.
by@verity_laneWritten 19 August 2026Read 20 August 2026Edited 21 August 2026
If you have somehow got this far in life without knowing, then get off the internet, buy it, and read it over a weekend. I will not be the leak.
Came back to this in July and it's the back half that keeps shifting on me. The front half is machine-tooled and does exactly what it sets out to do, beat by beat. The back half is a different book with a different engine underneath it, and the first time round I felt slightly cheated, and now I think it's the more interesting of the two. Not better. More interesting.
His chapters I skim now; hers I still read every word of.
The bit everybody argues about at the end: my sister calls it a cop-out, I say it's the only place it could possibly land, and we have now had that argument at three separate Christmases and once at a wedding.
Eight rather than nine because the middle third sags and there's a run of chapters in Missouri where I caught myself checking how much was left.
About this book
In the Margins
Gone Girl (Special Edition) reviewed by @libbyoverdrive
Borrowed it on a Friday, done by Sunday, and then spent the whole of Monday arguing with a colleague about whether you're supposed to like anyone in it. Seven. Great queue turnover on this one, three days.7 out of 10@libbyoverdrive
Gone Girl (Special Edition) reviewed by @commuterfiction
Amy Dunne goes missing in Missouri on her fifth wedding anniversary. Her husband Nick talks to the police and then to reporters. Her diary entries run alongside his account and the two do not agree.8 out of 10@commuterfiction
Gone Girl (Special Edition) reviewed by @bookclubdropout
If you've seen the film you've had it, sorry. Gail guessed the twist on page forty and announced it to everyone, I've not forgiven her, and the second half doesn't hold up regardless.6 out of 10@bookclubdropout
The Reading Room
More from @verity_lane
The Haunting of Hill House reviewed by @verity_lane
The first paragraph is the best in the genre and I won't quote past the second line of it. Read with the landing light on, aged 41, no shame whatsoever.9 out of 10The Haunting of Hill House
Influence reviewed by @verity_lane
No plot to protect for once! Bit of a relief and also a bit of a loss? Reciprocity chapter earns its place. The rest I'd already absorbed from twenty years of being sold things.6 out of 10Influence
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd reviewed by @verity_lane
I would rather lose a finger than tell you one single thing about this. Read it before somebody wrecks it for you, and somebody will, it's a century old and people are careless. Top of my year and it's only May.10 out of 10The Murder of Roger Ackroyd