Reader’s Note
9 out of 10
The shoes! The dolls. I ordered the second one before I turned the light off.
by@pageandvineWritten 17 July 2026Read 16 July 2026
Sign in to agreeNo one has agreed with this review yet
About this book
My Brilliant FriendElena FerranteIn the Margins
My Brilliant Friend reviewed by @bookclubdropout
This one split us clean down the middle.8 out of 10@bookclubdropout
2 readers agree with this reviewMy Brilliant Friend reviewed by @the_slow_reader
I was determined not to like it.8 out of 10@the_slow_reader
My Brilliant Friend reviewed by @mx_marginalia
Against my instincts I have joined a consensus, and the consensus is quite wrong about which of these two girls the novel actually belongs to.9 out of 10@mx_marginalia
5 readers agree with this review
The Reading Room
More from @pageandvine
Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat reviewed by @pageandvine
I cooked from it first9 out of 10Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat
The Alchemist reviewed by @pageandvine
It is warm water3 out of 10The Alchemist
The Shadow of the Wind reviewed by @pageandvine
Barcelona, rain, a bookshop, a cemetery of forgotten books — it is exactly as delicious as that sounds and about a chapter too pleased with itself. Winter, heating right up, hot chocolate, which is the correct way to take it.8 out of 10The Shadow of the Wind