Reader’s Note
I cooked from it first
by@pageandvineWritten 22 August 2026Read 22 August 2026
I bought this expecting a cookbook and got something closer to a driving lesson.
The four chapters are the whole business and I resisted them for about forty pages, because I have a shelf of cookbooks and I didn't think I needed a theory of anything. Then I salted a chicken the night before instead of an hour before, the way she says to, and it came out of the oven a different animal. I have not gone back since. That one change has done more for my cooking than a decade of following recipes to the letter.
The acid chapter is where I properly fell in. I'd spent years making things that were fine and flat and I could never work out what was missing, and the answer turned out to be a squeeze of something at the end, nearly every time. Now there is always a lemon in the house. It's a small stupid thing and it has quietly changed most of what I cook.
The illustrations aren't decoration and I want to be clear about that — the world map of fat, where every cuisine's cooking fat sits, is the clearest single page about food I have ever seen. I've photographed it and sent it to three people, one of whom sent it on to four more.
I cooked a whole Friday out of it once, for four people, and it was the least stressed I've ever been hosting, because I finally understood what each step was actually for and could tell by tasting whether it had happened yet. Dee asked what was different and I said I salt things earlier now, which sounds like nothing and is not nothing.
Where it's weaker: the recipes at the back are good but they aren't the reason to own it, and if you came purely for recipes you'll feel a bit short changed. She also writes like somebody who already has you on side, which I find charming and my sister finds smug. My sister is wrong, but I can see the case she is making.
My copy has a tomato thumbprint on the heat chapter that has been there two years and something greasy across the section on eggs, and that feels about right to me. A clean cookbook is a sad object.
There is a television version and it is lovely and it is not this. The programme gives you Samin being delighted in four countries; the book gives you the reasoning. I watched all of it and then went straight back to the book.
Nine. Not ten because the last section sags and because I want a second volume about bread that she hasn't written. The paper copy is heavy and gets splashed and I wouldn't have it any other way.
About this book
The Reading Room
More from @pageandvine
The Alchemist reviewed by @pageandvine
It is warm water3 out of 10The Alchemist
The Shadow of the Wind reviewed by @pageandvine
Barcelona, rain, a bookshop, a cemetery of forgotten books — it is exactly as delicious as that sounds and about a chapter too pleased with itself. Winter, heating right up, hot chocolate, which is the correct way to take it.8 out of 10The Shadow of the Wind
One Hundred Years of Solitude reviewed by @pageandvine
I drew the family tree on the back of an envelope and still lost track8 out of 10One Hundred Years of Solitude