Reader’s Note
Great house, bad house, saying nothing else.
by@verity_laneWritten 17 March 2026Read 14 March 2026
A young woman goes to a house in the mountains to check on her cousin. That's the setup, the setup is all you're getting, and the back cover gives you that much anyway.
What I can talk about is the house, which is the best thing here. Damp, English, wrong, and the writing makes you notice the wallpaper long before it makes you notice anybody's motives. Also the family, who are appalling in a way that felt fresh to me even though the ingredients aren't new.
I guessed a big piece of it around page 140 and I was about half right, which is honestly the ideal result? Right enough to feel clever, wrong enough to still get got at the end.
Where it lost a couple of points for me: the closing stretch goes somewhere very different in tone and I wasn't ready for it. My book club split straight down the middle and two of them stopped speaking to each other over it, which is the highest compliment a book club can pay anything.
Seventh on my list so far this year. Would sit higher on a different ending.
About this book
Mexican GothicSilvia Moreno-GarciaIn the Margins
Mexican Gothic reviewed by @bleakhouse_bex
Lovely house, silly answer6 out of 10@bleakhouse_bex
2 readers agree with this review
The Reading Room
More from @verity_lane
The Haunting of Hill House reviewed by @verity_lane
The first paragraph is the best in the genre and I won't quote past the second line of it. Read with the landing light on, aged 41, no shame whatsoever.9 out of 10The Haunting of Hill House
Gone Girl (Special Edition) reviewed by @verity_lane
You either know or you don't. I'm not the one who tells you.8 out of 10Gone Girl (Special Edition)
5 readers agree with this reviewInfluence reviewed by @verity_lane
No plot to protect for once! Bit of a relief and also a bit of a loss? Reciprocity chapter earns its place. The rest I'd already absorbed from twenty years of being sold things.6 out of 10Influence