Reader’s Note
Slow, and worth it.
by@theodore_pWritten 6 January 2026Read 4 January 2026
A student named Bethan told me in week four that she'd stopped reading somewhere around the discussion of regression to the mean, because the book kept catching her out and she was tired of being caught out. I have thought about that admission more than I have thought about most of the arguments in here. Kahneman is doing something the eighteenth-century moralists attempted and mostly botched: demonstrating, with evidence rather than wit, that the mind is not a reliable witness to itself. Mandeville would have adored him. Mandeville would also have found him rather slow.
Because it is slow. Parts I and II earn the reputation; Part III on overconfidence is the finest sustained stretch of exposition I have read in a popular science book, and I say that as someone who reads very few of them. Part IV, the prospect-theory material, is where the general reader quietly begins to skim, and I can hardly blame them. The final quarter is a man refusing to abandon a result he loves.
The prose is plain to the point of dryness, which suits the material. No metaphor is asked to carry weight it cannot bear. He tells you where the evidence is thin, which is more than most in the genre bother with, though a book published in 2011 could not know how much thinner some of it was about to get.
I still assign chapter 19. Every year. It does more for undergraduate essay writing than any style guide I own.
About this book
In the Margins
Thinking, Fast and Slow reviewed by @rereader
Second go, first since 2015. Half of it has fallen over in replication since — I kept checking chapters against my phone as I read, which is a strange way to spend an evening. The material on how badly we remember pain has held.7 out of 10@rereader
Thinking, Fast and Slow reviewed by @mx_marginalia
I was wrong about this one for about four years.8 out of 10@mx_marginalia
6 readers agree with this reviewThinking, Fast and Slow reviewed by @books_and_bins
Aye, alright. Half of it's stuff my granny knew and the other half's a graph I didnae need.6 out of 10@books_and_bins
The Reading Room
More from @theodore_p
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy reviewed by @theodore_p
Smiley reconstructing an old file in a rented room beats any car chase ever filmed. The real subject is institutional decline and the spying is only how it gets delivered. Fifty pages of tradecraft vocabulary, and then you simply have it.9 out of 10Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
Sapiens reviewed by @theodore_p
Very good lecturer, no archive.6 out of 10Sapiens
Letters from a Stoic reviewed by @theodore_p
Campbell's selection, not the complete letters. That matters.8 out of 10Letters from a Stoic