Skip to content
IBDB
← Back to @thebigsleepy's reviews

Reader’s Note

8 out of 10

January to something like June, and worth it

by@thebigsleepyWritten 20 May 2026Read 16 May 2026


I have wanted to read this since I was about nineteen, when a man in a pub told me I would love it. He was right, more or less, only forty years late.

At my rate a book like this stops being a story you follow and becomes a place you visit. I would be on Arrakis for ten minutes before the lamp went off, and then again the following night, and after a few months the desert felt like somewhere I had actually been. The stillsuits. The sand walk. The way water works out there, and spitting being a courtesy. All of that came through perfectly well.

What did not come through was the politics. There are a great many houses and a great many schemes, and I would take in a page of it, sleep on it, and lose most of it by the morning. I stopped trying to keep the Landsraad and the Guild and the rest of it straight somewhere around February and simply let it wash over me. That is my method with a lot of books now, if I'm honest, and I don't enjoy them any less for it.

The Baron is horrible in a way that has aged oddly. Jessica is the one I cared about, and I don't think the book quite knows that she is the best thing in it.

Eight. Slow going, but I was never once tempted to give it up, and at my speed that counts for a great deal.

Sign in to agreeNo one has agreed with this review yet

About this book

Cover of DuneDuneFrank Herbert

In the Margins

More on this book

The Reading Room

More from @thebigsleepy