Reader’s Note
Third, and it's going down a point a go.
by@rereaderWritten 11 July 2026Read 6 July 2026
2004, 2012, now. Nine, then eight, now seven, and I can be fairly specific about where the points went.
The road material is still the best of it. The House on the Rock. The roadside attractions, and the idea that America is bad ground for gods. Nobody else was writing that in 2001 and it's why the book mattered.
But the plot is a con trick with two twists in it, and once you know both, the middle turns into waiting. Shadow is a hole in the shape of a man. That worked for me twice, as a device. This time I wanted him to want something.
The interlude chapters, Coming to America, are better than the novel around them. I would read a collection of only those.
Also: I'd had Laura down as far more of a presence than she is. I had her in a dozen scenes. It's about five.
Seven. Ask me in 2032 and it might be a six, at which point I'll stop.
About this book
American GodsNeil GaimanThe Reading Room
More from @rereader
Thinking, Fast and Slow reviewed by @rereader
Second go, first since 2015. Half of it has fallen over in replication since — I kept checking chapters against my phone as I read, which is a strange way to spend an evening. The material on how badly we remember pain has held.7 out of 10Thinking, Fast and Slow
The Colour of Magic reviewed by @rereader
Second read. Should have left it alone.6 out of 10The Colour of Magic
4 readers agree with this reviewThe Hobbit reviewed by @rereader
Seventh, I think. Spreadsheet only goes back to 2003.10 out of 10The Hobbit