Reader’s Note
Second read. Should have left it alone.
by@rereaderWritten 6 August 2026Read 5 August 2026
Reread went badly on this one and I'm annoyed about it.
First time was 1997, a borrowed copy, and I remember laughing on a bus. Second time was last month and I finished it out of stubbornness. Who is this actually for now?
It's parody, and the things it is parodying have mostly stopped existing. If you haven't read much bad seventies sword and sorcery, the jokes are aimed past you. I have read plenty and they were still aimed past me, because I read that stuff so long ago that the targets have gone soft.
Rincewind works. The Luggage works. The structure doesn't. Four novellas stapled together and the last one simply stops.
Six, which is two points down on where I'd have put it from memory. That's the risk with this hobby and I knew it going in. Small Gods and Mort are the ones I am supposed to have loved, and I do, and this is where he was learning how to do them.
About this book
The Colour of MagicTerry PratchettThe Reading Room
More from @rereader
Thinking, Fast and Slow reviewed by @rereader
Second go, first since 2015. Half of it has fallen over in replication since — I kept checking chapters against my phone as I read, which is a strange way to spend an evening. The material on how badly we remember pain has held.7 out of 10Thinking, Fast and Slow
The Hobbit reviewed by @rereader
Seventh, I think. Spreadsheet only goes back to 2003.10 out of 10The Hobbit
American Gods reviewed by @rereader
Third, and it's going down a point a go.7 out of 10American Gods