Reader’s Note
A woman got on near Twyford, saw the cover, and did not stop talking for eleven minutes.
by@quietcarriageWritten 6 July 2026Read 3 July 2026
She sat down opposite, looked at the cover for a while, and then:
"Oh, you're on that one. Is it your first go?"
Yes.
"How far?"
Manderley's burning, I said. I've just got to the burning.
"Then you know nothing yet. Go back and read the first two pages again. Go on, afterwards. It's all sitting in there and you won't have seen a bit of it."
I said I had found the narrator quite hard going, all that flinching.
"She's twenty-one and nobody has ever asked her a question in her life. Of course she flinches."
Fair.
"It's Danvers, though. She's who it's for. She's the only person in that house who is actually grieving and this book will not let her have it."
She got off before I could ask her name. I did go back and read the first two pages again and she was completely right: the whole thing is sitting there in the dream, including the bit I had assumed was symbolic and isn't.
Eight. I have since found out Du Maurier didn't much care for being called a romantic novelist, and having read it I can see why. The marriage in this is a hostage situation with nicer curtains.
About this book
In the Margins
Rebecca reviewed by @plainjaneausten
the costume ball!!! I had to put the book down and walk round the kitchen for a bit. Steph asked if I was alright. I was not alright.9 out of 10@plainjaneausten
Rebecca reviewed by @verity_lane
The only line I'll quote is the first one, and you know it already.9 out of 10@verity_lane
1 reader agrees with this reviewRebecca reviewed by @bleakhouse_bex
Mrs Danvers!! A whole novel, and the two best characters in it are the housekeeper and a dead woman who never appears once. The narrator hasn't got a name and it took me half the book to notice.9 out of 10@bleakhouse_bex
The Reading Room
More from @quietcarriage
Siddhartha reviewed by @quietcarriage
Put-downable, and not kindly.6 out of 10Siddhartha
Just Kids reviewed by @quietcarriage
Ninety minutes stopped outside Reading. The book gets two sentences at the end, sorry.9 out of 10Just Kids
2 readers agree with this reviewStation Eleven reviewed by @quietcarriage
Read a novel about the end of the world on public transport, surrounded by strangers coughing, and I'd do it again! The Travelling Symphony in the snow. Survival is insufficient, yes, fine, put it on a caravan — it worked on me.9 out of 10Station Eleven