Reader’s Note
A hawk and a dead father.
by@an_ordinary_tuesdayWritten 26 August 2026Read 23 August 2026
Three books plaited together: a woman losing her father, a woman training a goshawk, and the strange broken life of T. H. White, who wrote The Sword in the Stone and who tried to train a hawk himself and made an appalling job of it.
The hawk is called Mabel and she is the most vividly real animal I've met on a page. Not cuddly. Not a symbol — or not only a symbol. A thing of pure wildness with a hooked face and enormous yellow feet and a heartbeat, and the writing about her is so precise that you can smell the mews and feel the jesses between your fingers.
What it is really about is what grief does to a person. She goes out into the fields and lets herself turn half hawk, because a hawk does not mourn and does not remember, and for a while she is not quite a person any more, and the book is completely honest about how far out she went. That took courage to write down.
The White chapters are where some readers get off the bus. I did not. I found him unbearably sad, this lonely frightened violent man taking it all out on a bird, and the way she keeps holding him up against herself is the cleverest piece of structure in the book.
Nine. It made me want to go outside, and books hardly ever do that.
About this book
In the Margins
H Is for Hawk reviewed by @saltmarsh
Mabel.9 out of 10@saltmarsh
H Is for Hawk reviewed by @quietcarriage
Hawk half: brilliant. White half: less.8 out of 10@quietcarriage
1 reader agrees with this reviewH Is for Hawk reviewed by @mossandink
Goshawk weather; I lost a week to it.10 out of 10@mossandink
The Reading Room
More from @an_ordinary_tuesday
Nineteen Eighty-four reviewed by @an_ordinary_tuesday
A Warning carved in cold stone.6 out of 10Nineteen Eighty-four
5 readers agree with this reviewSiddhartha reviewed by @an_ordinary_tuesday
The river is the best character in it and I mean that as the highest praise.8 out of 10Siddhartha
2 readers agree with this reviewThe Waste Land reviewed by @an_ordinary_tuesday
April is the cruellest month and this is the cruellest poem, and I mean that with love and a great deal of confusion.7 out of 10The Waste Land