Reader’s Note
Would I have joined the Greek class? Instantly. Shamefully. Yes.
by@tinyapartmentbigtbrWritten 10 April 2026Read 6 April 2026
Read it in the July heatwave with a fan pointed directly at my face, which is exactly the wrong weather for this novel, and I'd do it again.
Here's my position on the six of them: they're appalling. Snobbish, cruel, wildly pretentious, mostly horrible to each other, and I'd have moved into that house inside a week and been grateful for the invitation. The clothes! The dead languages! The total absence of anyone doing laundry!
Bunny is a nightmare and the book knows he's a nightmare, which makes the middle a deeply uncomfortable place to live for a fortnight. You're told what's happened on the first page, so all that's left is watching them come apart, and Tartt takes her time over it in a way that never once bothered me.
Where it loses marks: Camilla barely exists as a person and I closed the book with no clear idea what she wanted, and Richard is such a blank that I kept forgetting he was in the room.
Anyway, the practical outcome was that I bought a second-hand Greek grammar from a stall on the Cowley Road, which is now on the pile with everything else, unopened, mocking me.
About this book
The Secret HistoryDonna TarttIn the Margins
The Secret History reviewed by @mx_marginalia
Great novel, and it stops halfway.6 out of 10@mx_marginalia
The Secret History reviewed by @verity_lane
Everyone had read this except me, until March.8 out of 10@verity_lane
The Secret History reviewed by @bleakhouse_bex
I would have joined that class and I'd have been the first one caught9 out of 10@bleakhouse_bex
The Reading Room
More from @tinyapartmentbigtbr
The Ocean at the End of the Lane reviewed by @tinyapartmentbigtbr
Short enough that even I finished it.8 out of 10The Ocean at the End of the Lane
Dune reviewed by @tinyapartmentbigtbr
Look, I got there in the end (two attempts, one glossary) and the sandworms are worth it.7 out of 10Dune
Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell reviewed by @tinyapartmentbigtbr
Two winters. Finally finished.8 out of 10Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell