Reader’s Note
two writers swap genres, I'm in
by@plainjaneaustenWritten 14 August 2026Read 12 August 2026
the premise is exactly my sort of nonsense: two writers in neighbouring beach houses, one does literary misery and one does romance, and they bet that each can write the other's thing. and to be fair Henry actually does something with it, because the joke isn't that romance is silly, it's that both of them are hiding behind a genre.
January is funny in a way I honestly wasn't expecting. the running commentary going on in her head is sharp and I highlighted about six lines, which is six more than I normally manage.
but there's a whole strand about her dad and his secret second life that I did not want and did not ask for, and the book keeps putting it between me and the bit I turned up for. every time they got somewhere good: dad. and the cult research subplot is an awful lot of book to spend on something that resolves as quietly as it does.
also they take FOREVER, which is the genre and I knew what I was signing up for, but somewhere around three quarters through I said "just talk to each other" out loud and woke the dog up.
seven. I read it in the garden over two days last August with my legs going pink because I lost track of the time entirely, which is the correct way to do this one.
About this book
Beach ReadEmily HenryThe Reading Room
More from @plainjaneausten
Cheer Up Love reviewed by @plainjaneausten
the dogs. the DOGS.8 out of 10Cheer Up Love
4 readers agree with this reviewMe Before You reviewed by @plainjaneausten
cried, and I'm still cross about it5 out of 10Me Before You
The Time Traveler’s Wife reviewed by @plainjaneausten
the concept is unhinged and I love it and ALSO I have so many questions the book very much does not want me to ask?? seven. cried anyway. obviously.7 out of 10The Time Traveler’s Wife