Reader’s Note
Fungi, and a man who cannot stop grinning about them. I didn't mind a bit.
by@mossandinkWritten 6 September 2025Read 3 September 2025
October, the week the field behind the chapel came up in waxcaps — the pink ones, and the ones that smell of honey — which is the single week of the year in which I have any real expertise, so my timing was good.
He is so pleased about all of it! Every chapter has the tone of somebody who has just come in from the garden with something balanced on a piece of slate to show you. I braced myself for that to become wearing and it never did, mostly because the science underneath is properly difficult and he doesn't smooth it out on my behalf. The section on how a mycelial network solves a problem without anything you could sensibly call a decision-maker, I read three times and could not have explained afterwards, and I was perfectly content about that.
Two things I would push back on. He takes psilocybin and writes it up, and that is the least interesting chapter in the book, which I suspect surprised him. And the business at the end with the cider and his own fruiting bodies is a stunt. Charming, but a stunt.
The lichen chapter is the best thing here by a distance. A lichen is not one organism doing a job; it is a question about where an individual stops and something else starts. He lets that sit for a while without hammering it flat, which took more restraint than the rest of the book shows.
I have since gone and bought a hand lens and a small paper bag habit. My husband is not thrilled.
About this book
Entangled LifeMerlin SheldrakeIn the Margins
Entangled Life reviewed by @sam
Mushrooms! Genuinely.8 out of 10@sam
Entangled Life reviewed by @ivor_stack
Eight. I have opened enough foundations to have met the stuff repeatedly and never once wondered what it was doing down there. He is careful about what isn't known, which in this field is rarer than it should be.8 out of 10@ivor_stack
Entangled Life reviewed by @dr_bramble
Not plants! Not remotely plants, and I've never minded less. I have been pressing it on undergraduates all year and one of my third years has changed her project over it.10 out of 10@dr_bramble
The Reading Room
More from @mossandink
Meditations reviewed by @mossandink
Admirable, and airless.7 out of 10Meditations
The Hidden Life of Trees reviewed by @mossandink
Kind-hearted, and useful on beech and on how a wood holds water. He keeps telling me the trees are friends, are mothers, are talking; and each time he does it I trust the observation a little less. Fine for a beginner. Not for me.6 out of 10The Hidden Life of Trees
Piranesi reviewed by @mossandink
Weather indoors, of all things.9 out of 10Piranesi