Reader’s Note
The best thing on the picture book trolley, and it isn't close
by@margaretreadsWritten 18 November 2025Read 15 November 2025Edited 24 November 2025
You can't read this one badly. I have heard it read by a terrified student teacher, by a caretaker covering a wet break, and by a boy in Year 6 who could hardly decode a word of it, and every time the thing survived. The book does the work.
Sendak understood something almost nothing else on that trolley understood, which is that small children are frequently and genuinely furious, and that the fury is not naughtiness waiting to be corrected. Max goes, Max reigns, Max comes home, and the supper is still hot. He manages all of that without using the word love once.
Three double-page spreads with no text on them at all. Try getting that past a publisher now!
The parents who objected in my first year objected to the wolf suit, of all things. Mr Sowerby said something unrepeatable about them in the staffroom, and repeat it I shall not.
I bought a copy for Ruth, then for Ruth's two, and I shall buy another when the third one is ready. You cannot argue with something that survives three goes at one family.
About this book
In the Margins
Where the Wild Things Are reviewed by @dr_bramble
Night sixty of the only book8 out of 10@dr_bramble
The Reading Room
More from @margaretreads
Siddhartha reviewed by @margaretreads
A slim one, and I never have known where to shelve it8 out of 10Siddhartha
The Haunting of Hill House reviewed by @margaretreads
That opening paragraph! Nothing else in it reaches that pitch again, and I say so as somebody who lent it out constantly. Eleanor is superb; the house is a bit of a set. I'd take Jackson's short stories over it, honestly.7 out of 10The Haunting of Hill House
Becoming reviewed by @margaretreads
The South Side chapters are the book. Everything after the second campaign reads as though a committee sat in on it, politely. I've reserved it twice for other people since, which is my only real measure of anything.7 out of 10Becoming