Reader’s Note
I drew a diagram.
by@ivor_stackWritten 20 December 2025Read 16 December 2025
On the back of an envelope, in the first thirty pages: the names, the departments, who reported to whom, which of them had been abroad and when. I recommend doing the same. The book won't hold your hand and it is a better book for that, but there are eleven men to keep straight and four of them are called by two names apiece.
The construction is what I admired. It is an investigation conducted almost entirely by interview, so the thing is really a series of rooms with two men in each of them, and the plot advances by what one of them lets slip. Very little happens. Everything moves. The load is carried by the conversations, which means every one of them has to be doing structural work, and they are.
The Prideaux material is the strongest and it is placed exactly where the middle of the book would otherwise sag.
Nine. I was in my twenties when this world was supposedly running, and I've never worked anywhere with that quantity of dishonesty in it, though I did once work somewhere with a little, and the small version is recognisable enough to make the large one convincing.
About this book
Tinker Tailor Soldier SpyJohn Le CarréIn the Margins
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy reviewed by @theodore_p
Smiley reconstructing an old file in a rented room beats any car chase ever filmed. The real subject is institutional decline and the spying is only how it gets delivered. Fifty pages of tradecraft vocabulary, and then you simply have it.9 out of 10@theodore_p
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy reviewed by @commuterfiction
A retired officer looks for a mole.7 out of 10@commuterfiction
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy reviewed by @books_and_bins
Best of the lot.10 out of 10@books_and_bins
The Reading Room
More from @ivor_stack
The Making of the Atomic Bomb reviewed by @ivor_stack
The best of them.10 out of 10The Making of the Atomic Bomb
Project Hail Mary reviewed by @ivor_stack
The problem-solving I enjoyed enormously; the jokes I could have done without about a hundred times. Seven, and most of it is for the chapter where he works out the units.7 out of 10Project Hail Mary
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions reviewed by @ivor_stack
I lived through one of these. Permissible stress gave way to limit state design over about a decade, and the older men never converted; they simply retired. He has the mechanism right and nearly everything else vague. Eight.8 out of 10The Structure of Scientific Revolutions